CHRISTINE NORVELL
  • Writing
  • Speaker
  • Blog

Blog

"I turn my ear to a proverb. I explain my riddle with a lyre."
- Psalm 49:4

Writing Fiction and Teaching Writing

9/16/2021

3 Comments

 
Picture
I received a rejection last week. From one year ago. An agent whose work I admire had requested a full manuscript for my middle grade novel.​
I enjoyed the read – you’ve got a great voice here, and I really liked the concept, but in the end, I just didn’t fall enough in love to be able to offer representation.”
For those in the writing trenches, you’ll recognize the wording of a standardized rejection. It’s neither encouraging nor discouraging. From an agent, it could mean “Your story is not for me” or they (or their assistant) really weren’t captured enough to read it, let alone provide feedback.

Rejection is an odd thing for me as a literature teacher because I delight in words. Reading, absorbing, experiencing, teaching, analyzing, writing. As a teacher, I hope to never suck the joy out of the reading experience for my students.

I certainly endured more than one class in high school and college that did that well. Analyze. Pull the story apart. Pick it to death. Put it back together. Mash it into the meaning the teacher wants.

Textbooks can often be structured that way too. I wonder if many are built for overworked teachers, to make their lives easier. They might include commentary on a theme, different levels of discussion questions, and ideas for essays. Sometimes I’d rather they didn’t. It can be too prescriptive because the textbook authors are giving you their meaning. On the surface, it’s like saying that teachers and students alike are incapable of thinking through these things. It’s practically miraculous that any student comes out of that system having enjoyed the story still.

And that’s the odd parallel.

In writing fiction, I have to be aware of all of the parts, like ingredients in a recipe. I know what I’m making, but every separate thing must come together. I have to be intentional. I have to be aware of word choice, lexile, backstory, setting, point of view, tone, characters’ needs and wants, the arc of each character, the arc of the plot, scene structure—so many things.

It’s the opposite of how I read and how I teach reading and writing. I realize now that I most appreciate a holistic approach. I do think all of the parts come together as a whole, a synchronicity of sorts. For some writers it comes naturally. For others, like me, it comes through labor and training, especially through the imitation of others.

​And that gives me every hope that as I teach my students parts of the whole, I can do it in a way that doesn’t suck the joy out of the reading experience. We don’t have to notice absolutely every thing in a story to enjoy it. As I lead a class, I can model that. I can choose to emphasize perhaps two or three things an author has constructed. As I am aware, even hyper aware of what an author has done in the story structure, I am able to encourage my students to appreciate the grand design.
3 Comments
Jackie
9/17/2021 10:50:18 am

Enjoyed reading this! You inspire me!

Reply
AmyLu Riley link
9/17/2021 12:14:58 pm

Well said! And I'm glad you are teaching your holistic approach to others.

Reply
Christine
9/17/2021 12:25:26 pm

Thank you, AmyLu!

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Categories

    All
    Bible
    Book Review
    Comments On Classics
    Creation
    Philosophy
    Poetry
    Reading
    Teaching
    Writing

    RSS Feed



© COPYRIGHT 2018-2025 CHRISTINE NORVELL. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
SITEMAP
  • Writing
  • Speaker
  • Blog